The New York Times decided to reject John McCain's Op-Ed piece a week after accepting a piece by Barack Obama. The whole situation between McCain and the Times is one that could have been resolved prior to the McCain sending an Op-Ed if the Times has in advance sent the McCain camp a list of how they wanted them to phrase their Op-Ed. Instead, one person decided that the Op-Ed was not good enough and compared the piece to Obama piece by saying that they are looking for a format similarly to Obama's piece which presented new ideas or flip flops some might say on Iraq.
However to be fair, McCain's Op-Ed piece should have been accepted because this is what they wanted the New York Times readers to read. The Times does not reserve the right to say what type of Op-Ed they are looking for because did they send this message to the Obama campaign in advance prior to their submission. McCain and Obama are two different people so you cannot expect McCain to revise his Op-Ed in order for it to look similar to Obama's piece. That is not the way politics are and for that reason, McCain drafted his Op-Ed the way he felt would grab the Times readers attention. Op-Ed's are opinion pieces and this is the opinion of how McCain views the Iraq war and his stance on the war will not change so the Times should accept it and don't force him to.
I don't know what Op-Ed editor David Shipley was thinking but it was not fair and Shipley should be have shown fairness in his judgment by first accepting McCain's Op-Ed than perhaps publishing a piece the next day or next week comparing McCain's and Obama's Op-Ed piece by pointing out why McCain's piece is not what the Times was looking for and how it was too critical of Obama and not real clear on McCain's vision for the future of Iraq like Obama's Op-Ed was. Therefore Shipley's letter to the McCain camp would not have been needed and that would not have made the McCain camp want to compose a video about the media's blatant love for Obama. So for now, the McCain camp and even some rank and file Republicans plan to tell the New York Times to print McCain's Op-Ed by writing to the paper expressing their dislike for their recent decision in regards to not printing McCain's Op-Ed.
Now what really makes this whole controversy between the Times and McCain bad is that Shipley not only rejected McCain's Op-Ed but he went on vacation afterwards by stating he will be out of office all this week if the McCain camp decides to resubmit the piece this week. That was the most hilarious piece of the letter sent to the McCain camp that I saw. You reject something and in the same breath tell them you are going to be out of the office the rest of the week but you can be in touch with blah, blah if you decide to resubmit your Op-Ed piece with the revisions I have suggest.
References:
No comments:
Post a Comment